Letters from a Psychotherapist

Letters from a Psychotherapist

Poems & Prose

The Third Man

A short story

j.e. moyer, LPC's avatar
j.e. moyer, LPC
Jun 24, 2026
∙ Paid

The hallway stretched out before him, a ribbon of burgundy carpet and faded floral wallpaper, vividly, heartbreakingly, 1969.

Phil stepped from the bedroom, his bare feet sinking into carpet his mother — long dead now — had ripped out fifty years ago. The geometry was wrong, though. The staircase had moved to the wrong side. The ceiling rose into a darkness no house this old should have held. Under the smell of dust and bacon grease ran something sharper, something with a tang of metal that caught the back of his throat — the smell of another person in the room, the way air goes thick when it’s no longer just yours.

He walked toward the next door. It stood ajar, leaking a warm amber light onto the floorboards.

He pushed it open. A man sat on the edge of a twin bed.

The stranger looked up. He wore a stretched undershirt, and his face had the same tired creases Phil knew from his own mirror. Not a twin. An echo.

“You feel it too.” Not a question, really. “Like the house is holding its breath.”

Phil nodded. Something in his chest loosened. “I thought I was losing my mind. It’s my childhood, but—”

“But the math doesn’t work.” The man stood. “I’m Julian. There’s a third room. That’s where the air gets heavy.”

They moved down the corridor together. The light thinned as they walked, and by the time they reached the last door, the dark had pooled so thick neither of them crossed the threshold. They only looked.

The room was stripped to plaster. No carpet. A single, unmade cot, and on it, a third man.

He didn’t look up. He sat with the kind of stillness that isn’t rest — the coiled stillness of something held in a crate too small for it. A man’s shape, but nothing in it moved like a man. The light around him seemed to bend, the way heat bends a road in August.

Phil and Julian didn’t speak. They didn’t have to. Whatever this was, it lived here. It was the reason the staircase had moved.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of j.e. moyer, LPC.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 john moyer, M. Ed. LPC NCC · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture