Can We Let Go of Clutter Guilt?
The Pathologization of Clutter in Neurodiversity
Massively successful people, from Albert Einstein to Steve Jobs, have been known for their somewhat messy workspaces. Clutter is often pathologized in neurodivergent individuals, but this judgmental attitude can be counterproductive and detrimental. Understanding why clutter is pathologized and why negative perspectives need reevaluation is crucial for fostering a more inclusive and supportive environment for neurodivergent individuals, who often bring extraordinary gifts to the world.
Why Clutter is Pathologized
Cognitive & Sensory Challenges
ADHD: Individuals with ADHD frequently struggle with executive function skills, such as organization, time management, and prioritization. A cluttered environment can worsen these difficulties, making it harder to focus and complete tasks.
Autism: Many autistic individuals have heightened sensory sensitivities, making cluttered spaces overwhelming or distressing. They may also prefer order and routine, which clutter disrupts.
OCD: For those with OCD, clutter can trigger compulsive behaviors and anxiety. The need to organize or clean in a specific way can be disrupted by clutter, leading to increased distress.
Social & Cultural Expectations
We often equate a perfectly neat, organized space with competence and self-control. Neurodivergent individuals, whose environments may not meet these standards, can face judgment and stigmatization, reinforcing the pathologization of clutter.
Cultural narratives around productivity and success frequently link them to organized, minimalist spaces, creating additional pressure on neurodivergent individuals to conform.
Impact on Daily Functioning
Too much clutter can impede the daily functioning of neurodivergent individuals by making it difficult to find necessary items, complete tasks efficiently, or maintain routines. This impact is often highlighted as a reason to pathologize clutter.
The inability to manage clutter can lead to practical consequences, such as missed deadlines or appointments, further emphasizing clutter as a problem needing intervention. However, not all clutter causes such issues.
Professional & Medical Perspectives
Clinicians and therapists often emphasize structured and organized environments as part of managing neurodivergent conditions. While this advice aims to support individuals, it can inadvertently pathologize clutter by framing it as something to be controlled.
The medicalization of neurodivergent conditions focuses on behaviors that deviate from the norm, with clutter often judged as a negative symptom to be addressed.
Mental Health Implications
Excessive clutter can exacerbate common mental health issues among neurodivergent individuals, such as anxiety and depression, leading to its pathologization as a factor needing intervention. However, general messiness does not always rise to this level.
Conversely, clutter might be viewed as a result of underlying chronic stress or executive dysfunction, reinforcing its negative connotation.
Pathologizing Clutter Can Be Counterproductive
Respecting Individual Preferences
Everyone has unique organizational styles and tolerance levels for clutter. For some neurodivergent individuals, a certain level of clutter can be comforting or functional. Recognizing and respecting these differences can foster a more inclusive understanding of a "healthy" environment.
Autonomy & Self-Determination
Pathologizing clutter can undermine an individual's autonomy by imposing external standards of order that may not align with their preferences. Allowing neurodivergent individuals to determine their own comfort with clutter respects their right to self-determination.
Functional Clutter
Clutter can sometimes serve a functional purpose, such as keeping frequently used items within easy reach or providing visual task reminders. For some neurodivergent individuals, this "organized chaos" can enhance productivity and reduce anxiety.
Mental Health & Wellbeing
Enforcing strict organizational standards can increase stress and anxiety, especially if individuals find comfort in a certain level of clutter. It is more helpful to focus on whether clutter negatively impacts their daily life and wellbeing.
Recognizing that clutter can be neutral or even positive for some can alleviate unnecessary guilt or shame associated with not meeting societal norms.
Challenging Normative Standards
Societal norms around cleanliness and order are often arbitrary and culturally constructed. Challenging these norms can help reduce stigma around neurodivergent living spaces and promote a more diverse understanding of functional environments.
By questioning these standards, we can shift towards a more inclusive approach that accommodates different ways of living and organizing.
Individualized Approaches
Therapeutic and support interventions should be tailored to the individual's needs rather than applying a one-size-fits-all solution. For those who find a certain level of clutter manageable and comforting, the focus should be on supporting their unique needs rather than enforcing decluttering.
Encouraging neurodivergent individuals to find their own balance between order and clutter can be more empowering and effective than imposing external judgments.
Recognition of Adaptive Strategies
Neurodivergent individuals often develop adaptive strategies to navigate their environments. For some, a degree of clutter may be part of these strategies, helping them cope with sensory sensitivities, executive function challenges, or other aspects of their neurodivergence.
Appreciating and valuing these strategies as valid ways of managing one's space and tasks can lead to better support and understanding.
Rather than pathologizing clutter universally for neurodivergent individuals, adopting a flexible, person-centered approach is more helpful. This approach respects individual preferences and functional needs, acknowledges the diversity of organizational styles, and challenges societal norms that may not serve everyone well. By doing so, we can create environments that truly support the wellbeing and autonomy of the neurodivergent, and us all.
A clean desk is often a sign of an empty mind.
The famous creatives that a had messy desk and why you should too
Some famously cluttered offices
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Letters from a Psychotherapist to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.